We’ve got a top contender for Atlanta’s best cupcake (in my book, at least)! The recommendations, high ratings, and online accolades did not go unnoticed, and I finally made it to sweet, PIECE OF CAKE (you can read of my failed, first attempt here)! And let me just tell you, everything I read was true. Heavens to Betsy, their cupcakes rock the house!
I met up with a friend of mine, who had the beautiful idea of a mid-week, mid-day sugar snack. Which couldn’t have come at a better time, seeing as I was suffering from an acute case of cupcake withdraw. Two and a half weeks I went without cupcakes! May be a new record…that I’m not at all proud of. Another record breaker that day – the weather. Lord Almighty, I’m pretty sure Wednesday July 13, 2011 was the hottest day of my life. Turns out it only hit 96, but I can now say that whole Hotlanta thing is no myth. You’d think that a popsicle, frozen yogurt, ice cream, what have you, would’ve hit the spot, but oh no! A half-dozen of Piece of Cake’s small cupcakes put a skippy skip in my step.
Piece of Cake is a bakery veteran. They’ve been around 26 years and that time has served them well. They’ve perfected cake consistency to a T. We’re talking soft, spongy, fresh, moist, flavorful cake that doesn’t crumble apart in your hand – that’s a piece of art. Their cake/frosting ratio is respectable. It’s as, I believe, cupcakes were intended to be. No risk of frosting shock found here. But boy of boy, there’s just the right amount of sugar stirred (and love, I’m guessing) into those cupcake creations to make any sweet tooth sigh with relief.
So back to my half-dozen, small cupcakes – I selected the Caramel, Coconut, Lemon, Orange, Red Velvet and Yellow (w/chocolate frosting) Cupcakes. Three were had on the spot, well, on the pretty patio of Henri’s Bakery just a short distance away. (Gotta give my props to them for not shooing us away, considering they sell cupcakes too! ) I went to town on the Carmel Cupcake first – sweet Mary Jane, that thing was good. Next up, the Coconut Cupcake – hold the phone, this cupcake is not messing’ around. At this point, I’m thinking “why, oh why, did I go with the small cupcakes?!” I wanted more. So I went in for cupcake #3, the Vanilla (w/chocolate frosting), which is like edible nostalgia. Later that evening, I presented Steve with his half of my Piece of Cake catch. I sat right by his side as he sat down to enjoy, and asked for a bite the second he bit into each of the three cupcakes. What he calls mooching, I call research. The goodness continued, and the only downside I observed was the Lemon Cupcake lacking that zesty zing. Overall, Steve commended the cake consistency as well and deemed them tasty! When I threw out the bold statement of these being Atlanta’s best, thinking he was right there with me, he surprised me with his nod to CamiCakes. Soooo, you know what that mean folks? A blind taste is in order! Let’s do this (insert dramatic music here)…maybe next week, stay tuned for that endeavor. Until then, Piece of Cake still has a piece of my heart as well as spot on the Top 10!
Allow me to break it down for you…
PIECE OF CAKE / 3215 Roswell Rd. Atlanta, GA / www.pieceofcakeinc.com / Other locations = 10971 Crabapple Rd. Suite 1300 Roswell, GA and 307 E. College Ave. Suite A Decatur, GA
Large = $2.75 each / $14.75 half dozen / $29.50 dozen
Small = $2.25 each / $12 half-dozen / $24 dozen
Mini = $16.50 dozen
2. Room temperature: Yes
3. Size: The large cupcakes were definitely on the plump size, but not plump enough for me to share half of graciously. The small-sized cupcakes look awfully similar to mini cupcakes…maybe a smidge bigger than your average mini. And I didn’t spot any mini cupcakes on the day of my visit, so I’m afraid I can’t report back on that department. Anyone out there ever have a mini cupcake from Piece of Cake? In terms of size, what would you compare it to?
4. Vegan or gluten-free options: Not in cupcake form. But they do have a case full of gluten-free goodies (frozen) from Pure Knead, a “dedicated bakery specializing in allergy friendly fare”.
5. To-go packaging: White cardboard box with red bow print on top (cute!) and dividers inside.
6. Milk for sale?: No beverages, so you gotta take your thirst somewhere else. (I say that in the nicest way possible.)
7. Other treats for non-cupcake enthusiasts you may have in tow: For on the spot enjoyment, there’s chocolate chip cookies, shortbread cookies, tarts, brownies, cheese straws, slices of cake and pound cake. Then you can either order (and ship if need be!) layer and/or pound cakes, as well as pick up a gift of chocolate-covered peanuts, bag of malt balls, jar of gum balls, yogurt covered pretzels, mini chocolate chip cookies, pimped out popcorn (i.e. drizzled with chocolate and the like). Candles, napkins, paper plates, and greeting cards are all available for your party needs, too!
8. Ambiance: It’s a darling little shop filled with sunlight and sugary aromas. Stepping inside feels familiar even though I’ve never been before. No place to sit though (bummer), so you do need to plan on eating elsewhere. May I suggest your car? Because it’s just wrong to wait more than a minute to eat these rock star baked goods.
9. Service: Excellent! I loved how friendly/down-to-earth/easy-going the staff was.
10. Three words to describe the PIECE OF CAKE experience:
Thanks K, for the fun idea and good company!